Sven Amann
Are Code Reviews Worth It? Insights from 16 Years of Review Data
#1about 2 minutes
Proving the value of code reviews with data
The talk aims to provide quantitative data from 16 years of development to convince management of the benefits of code reviews.
#2about 3 minutes
Context of the 16-year development data set
An overview of the Teamscale product, its 1.5 million line codebase, and the team's development velocity provides context for the data analysis.
#3about 3 minutes
The asynchronous code review workflow in practice
The team uses a feature branch workflow with asynchronous reviews in GitLab, where the reviewer has the final authority to merge.
#4about 2 minutes
Defining value vs cost for code review analysis
The analysis frames the "worth" of code reviews by comparing their value (code improvement, knowledge sharing) against their cost (developer time).
#5about 2 minutes
Analyzing the time cost of the review cycle
An analysis of time logged on tickets reveals the distribution of time spent in the "in review" and "in rework" phases.
#6about 6 minutes
Investigating outliers where review time is high
An example ticket shows how scope creep and implementing new requirements during the review cycle can significantly inflate review time data.
#7about 4 minutes
Quantifying the cost and value of code reviews
Data shows reviews add 33% to development time while providing an average of 1.6 bug fixes and 5 maintainability improvements per ticket.
#8about 1 minute
Conclusion: Weighing the costs against the benefits
Weighing the 33% additional time cost against the benefits of bug fixes, maintainability improvements, and knowledge sharing confirms their value.
Related jobs
Jobs that call for the skills explored in this talk.
MARKT-PILOT GmbH
Stuttgart, Germany
Remote
€75-90K
Senior
Java
TypeScript
+1
Hubert Burda Media
München, Germany
€80-95K
Intermediate
Senior
JavaScript
Node.js
+1
Matching moments
02:55 MIN
Why developers often undervalue their time and paid tools
Developer Time Is Valuable - Use the Right Tools - Kilian Valkhof
01:32 MIN
Organizing a developer conference for 15,000 attendees
Cat Herding with Lions and Tigers - Christian Heilmann
03:58 MIN
Making accessibility tooling actionable and encouraging
Developer Time Is Valuable - Use the Right Tools - Kilian Valkhof
03:16 MIN
Improving the developer feedback loop with specialized tools
Developer Time Is Valuable - Use the Right Tools - Kilian Valkhof
06:46 MIN
How AI-generated content is overwhelming open source maintainers
WeAreDevelopers LIVE – You Don’t Need JavaScript, Modern CSS and More
07:27 MIN
Comparing software maintenance to tattoo cover-ups
Devs vs. Marketers, COBOL and Copilot, Make Live Coding Easy and more - The Best of LIVE 2025 - Part 3
04:57 MIN
Increasing the value of talk recordings post-event
Cat Herding with Lions and Tigers - Christian Heilmann
04:09 MIN
The emerging market for fixing AI-generated code
Devs vs. Marketers, COBOL and Copilot, Make Live Coding Easy and more - The Best of LIVE 2025 - Part 3
Featured Partners
Related Videos
28:09The AI-Ready Stack: Rethinking the Engineering Org of the Future
Jan Oberhauser, Mirko Novakovic, Alex Laubscher & Keno Dreßel
26:35How to Optimize Non-Coding Time
Yishai Beeri
26:46Keep your code refactorable
Gerrit Stapper
24:19Git for Code Reviews
Johannes Haux
43:00Shipping Quality Software In Hostile Environments
Luka Kladaric
45:28Build a CI/CD pipeline to automate code reviews and ensure code quality
Julien Delange
30:40The Clean as You Code Imperative
Olivier Gaudin
26:38State of DevEx 2025: Navigating the AI Revolution and Developer Experience
Andrew Boyagi
Related Articles
View all articles
From learning to earning
Jobs that call for the skills explored in this talk.
Confideck GmbH
Vienna, Austria
Remote
Intermediate
Senior
Node.js
MongoDB
TypeScript
Code Healers LLC
Hinesville, United States of America
Remote
€30-40K
Intermediate
Senior
.NET
React
JavaScript
+2
Visonum GmbH
Remote
Junior
Intermediate
React
Redux
TypeScript
